Our method
How we choose
We gather the evidence that already exists for each product, weigh it in the same order every time, and link every source so you can check it yourself.
What we look at, in order
- Certification. Is the exact product listed in an official directory? We check NSF's listings, IAPMO R&T's directory and the Water Quality Association's Gold Seal database. A listing means an accredited body tested the product and keeps auditing the factory. "Tested to", "meets" or "exceeds" a standard is not a certification.
- Published lab data. Performance data sheets and test reports for the specific model, and who ran the test. A report from an independent lab counts for more than one from the brand or its suppliers.
- Independent test results. Measurements by outlets that test products themselves, credited and linked. We note the conditions, because a single test in cold water isn't the same as a certification test run hot over a filter's full life.
- Cost of ownership. Price plus replacement cartridges or salt over five years, at the maker's own intervals.
- Owner complaints. Patterns in critical reviews: leaks, pressure loss, cartridges that seize or clog.
Saunas and cold plunges
There's no water-treatment certification for a sauna or a cold plunge, so the checks change. We look for an electrical safety listing (ETL or UL) on the exact model, published EMF test reports for infrared saunas and who ran them, the materials and wood, the warranty, running costs, and the same owner-complaint patterns.
What we won't do
- Rank a product higher because it pays a commission. Some of our top picks have no affiliate program at all.
- Pass on a brand's health claims as fact when the evidence doesn't back them, such as a shower filter curing eczema.
- Call a product certified unless we've found it in an official directory.
Keeping it current
Every guide shows when it was last updated and when its data was checked. Prices, certifications and test results change, so we re-check our guides every three months. If you spot something out of date, tell us and we'll check it.